Effect of Interactive Reading Based on Arabic Stories on Inferential and Critical Reading Comprehension among Middle-School Students

Main Article Content

Manal Salih Mahdi

Abstract

This study distinguished two related but non-equivalent processes in advanced reading comprehension: generating an inference from clues distributed across a text and evaluating whether the available evidence adequately supports that inference. Collapsing these processes into a single score may conceal instructionally meaningful differences in response. The study estimated the effect of interactive reading based on Arabic stories on total, inferential, and critical reading comprehension among second-year intermediate students, adjusting for baseline performance and school and examining whether baseline inferential performance moderated the response. A two-school quasi-experimental pretest-posttest design enrolled 120 students, with 30 intervention and 30 control students in each school and random allocation within school. The four-week program used four printed Arabic stories. Both groups studied the same stories for approximately 40 minutes per lesson with the same teacher; the intended contrast was the mode of text processing. The intervention routine centered on textual clues, interpretation building, alternative explanations, and evaluation of evidential adequacy. Comprehension was assessed with two independent 32-item forms equally divided between inferential and critical comprehension; total-score internal consistency was acceptable to good (KR-20=.702 and .784 for Forms A and B). Complete pretest-posttest data were available for 117 students. ANCOVA models adjusted for baseline score and school, examined treatment-by-baseline and treatment-by-school interactions, and applied Holm correction to secondary outcomes. The adjusted effect on total comprehension was 4.545 points, SE=0.529, 95% CI [3.497, 5.593], t(113)=8.591, p<.001, partial η²=.395; the adjusted effect on critical comprehension was 3.019 points, SE=.362, 95% CI [2.303, 3.735], t(113)=8.351, p<.001, partial η²=.382. Inferential comprehension showed a significant treatment-by-baseline interaction, b=-.294, SE=.135, p=.032. Conditional effects were 2.257 points at a low baseline level, 1.523 at the mean, and .789 at a high baseline level; the high-baseline effect was not statistically significant at .05. The data provided no statistical evidence that the treatment effect differed between schools. Thus, critical comprehension showed a clear gain, whereas inferential gains depended on students' starting level.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Salih Mahdi, M. (2026). Effect of Interactive Reading Based on Arabic Stories on Inferential and Critical Reading Comprehension among Middle-School Students. Al-Ma’moon College Journal , 46(2), 25–39. Retrieved from https://journal.almamonuc.edu.iq/index.php/jac/article/view/277
Section
Articles